Bill and Charlie have been sent to a small town near an Ute reservation. They tried dealing with T.J. Gingle who is a major player in the town but he wanted twice the price for wore out horses. They spot three men beating up a lone man in an alley. After breaking up the fight, they help the man, an Ute, with his wounds who Bill suddenly recognizes. Bill caught him as a young Ute brave and turned him over to the Army. He now goes by the name John Turnbull and graduated from Columbia Law School back East. He is now trying to represent his Ute tribe against Gingle and others who want to grab their land for development. John's partner, Jacob Solomon, is helping by being the lawyer of record due to the local judge, Judge Burkhardt, keeping John from practicing. Bill decides to buy the horses they need from the Utes which gives them the money they need to file their lawsuit. This puts Bill and Charlie in the middle of the land fight which turns nasty when hired gun, Jack Thorne, kills ...