Vince Jackson meets Harvey Dodds in a stable at Cheyenne. Dodds has paid Jackson $300 to leave his daughter alone, but Jackson has reneged on his promise. He puts on a shooting demo by singing Dodds' coat with bullets but his partner Hutch stops him before he puts a bullet in Dodds head. Meanwhile, in Cheyenne, Kitty McAllen is being stood up by Slim who has to ride a stage hoping to catch road bandits. Kitty is miffed as he leaves, so when she runs into Vince Jackson at a restaurant as she waits for her father Fred, they accept Vince's offer for dinner. The next day Kitty and her father, with Vince, take the stage to their home in Laramie with a stop at Slim's ranch. Kitty not only ignores Slim but stands him up that night for a dance to attend with Vince. Slim and Jess are not fooled by Vince's slick clothes and manners but Kitty soon finds herself the target of Vince's extortion plan.