Things go wrong for Jim when he talks to God about having women be more like men. When Cheryl and Dana become just like Jim and Andy. Jim asks God to make men be more like women, but they turn into overly sensitive women.
Cheryl tells Jim to wear an ID badge when he goes running in the morning, but he does not want to. When he has an accident on his run, he is taken to the hospital without ID. Jim realizes he needs to take precautions for his family.
Cheryl goes to Florida to care for her mother when she is sick, leaving Jim alone to take care of the children. When neighborhood mom's find out Jim is struggling at home, they all pitch in to help. Each one thinks they are the only helper.
Jim still struggles with household duties while Cheryl is out of town, but has real problems when Ruby asks to go shopping for a training bra. Jim asks Dana to be the temporary mom for shopping. Turns out, Ruby is getting ready for a date.
Andy remembers the dinner gift card Jim gave him for his last birthday the day before it's due to expire and asks Jim to accompany him. The only problem is Jim felt slighted in giving it to Andy so he's already cashed it in.
Andy may have hit the jackpot with the new lady in his life, but Jim may have screwed it up while agreeing to chaperon the lady's two daughters who accompany his own to a teen aged girls' concert and loses them all.