In 1996, Renner starred in a lesser-known murder mystery TV movie, A Nightmare Come True, where he played the son of a husband mistreating his wife until she disappears –all based on true events.
"It really doesn't surprise me that this is true," Renner told Et after reading the script. "I find out the true story and I'm like, you know what? I buy it. I don't doubt it. People are nuts. They're nuts."
Watch: Bradley Cooper Sports Long Blonde Locks in First 'Et' Interview
Rocking the signature male '90s uniform – a plaid button down shirt and long flowing hair -- Jeremy told us the challenges he faced while filming to ensure he doesn't give away the ending.