Cast overview, first billed only: | |||
Burgess Meredith | ... | Mio Romagna | |
Margo | ... | Miriamne Esdras | |
Eduardo Ciannelli | ... | Trock Estrella | |
John Carradine | ... | Bartolomio Romagna | |
Edward Ellis | ... | Judge Gaunt | |
Maurice Moscovitch | ... | Esdras | |
Paul Guilfoyle | ... | Garth Esdras | |
Stanley Ridges | ... | Shadow | |
Mischa Auer | ... | Radical | |
Willard Robertson | ... | Policeman in the Square | |
Alec Craig | ... | Hobo | |
![]() |
Myron McCormick | ... | Carr |
Helen Jerome Eddy | ... | Maria Romagna | |
Barbara Pepper | ... | Girl | |
Fernanda Eliscu | ... | Piny |
Immigrant radical Bartolomeo Romagna is falsely condemned and executed for a payroll robbery. Years later, his son Mio sets out to find the truth of the crime and to bring to account the gangster Trock Estrella. Written by Jim Beaver <jumblejim@prodigy.net>
Winterset starts out beautifully and profoundly. The story flows well, but the latter scenes are so implausibly constrained that I ended up losing sympathy for the characters. The dialog was hard to make sense of at times, and many of the movie's sequences look like dark scenes from a bad dream... you know, the kind of situation you just can't escape from.
It looks as though, in the transition to turning the stage play into a movie, the makers never gave much thought to overcoming the obvious limitations that the stage imposes on what we now think of as the "action sequences".
I don't regret the time spent watching Winterset. It was interesting, but as a movie (and even allowing for its vintage) it was just "OK".