Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose: The Forgotten Hero (2005)

Regista:

Shyam Benegal

Writers:

Atul Tiwari (writer)
Shama Zaidi (writer)

Data di uscita:

13 maggio 2005 (India)

Genere:

Drama

Slogan:

Extreme times call for extreme action and extraordinary people...The Indian Struggle for Independence. Peopled by great men and greater heroes...And sometimes, there comes along a figure that stands out even in such distinguished company.

Plot:

The film, which is about the last five years of the Indian leader Subhas Chandra Bose's life, also includes his life's story in flashback sequences. However, it does not cover the controversy surrounding Bose's death.

Plot Keywords:

Historical | British Italian | Hero | Soldier | War

Recensioni degli utenti:

boring, embarrassing and long...

Cast

Ila Arun	...	Ranu U. Malhotra
Pankaj Berry	...	Aabid Khan
Nicolas Chagrin	...	General Auchinlek
Nalini Chatterjee	...	Meera
Pradeep Kumar Das	...	Servant
Divya Dutta	...	Ila Bose
Chris England	...	CID Chief
Arindham Ghosh	...	Subhas Chandra Bose's Cousin
Rajit Kapoor	...	Abid Hasan
Ahmed Khan	...	Mian Akbar
Shakeel Khan	...	Sarat Bose
Kulbhushan Kharbanda	...	Uttamchand Malhotra
Sachin Khedekar	...	Subhas Chandra Bose
Howard Lee	...	Bengal Governer
Kunal Mitra	...	Ashok Bose
Samiran Mukherjee	...	Subhas Chandra Bose's Cousin
Rohan Nicol	...	CID Officer
Lal Babu Pandit	...	Checkpost Policeman
Florian Panzner	...	Alexander Werth
Surendra Rajan	...	Mohandas Karamchand 'Mahatma' Gandhi
Charu Rohatgi	...	Bibavati
Alaknanda Roy	...	Prabhavati Bose
Ashiesh Roy	...	Spy Police 2 (as Aashish Roy)
Rajeshwari Sachdev	...	Capt. Lakshmi Sehgal
Udo Schenk	...	Adolf Hitler
Jishu Sengupta	...	Sisir Bose
Gen Seto	...	Ambassador Oshima
Rakesh Shrivastav	...	Spy Police 1
Arindam Sil	...	Jail Warden
Suneel Sinha
Sandeep Srivastava	...	Nambiar
Lalit Tiwari	...	Checkpost Policeman
Christian Willis	...	Jail Superintendent
Rajpal Yadav	...	Bhagat Ram Talwar
Arif Zakaria

Alias:

Bose: The Forgotten Hero (India: English title) (working title)

Durata:

208 min

Nazionalità:

India

Lingua:

Inglese

Colore:

Colore

Aspect Ratio:

2.35 : 1

Divieti:

UK:15

Luoghi delle riprese:

Berlin, Germany

Company:

Sahara India Media Communication Ltd.

Curiosità:

The title description of Netaji, "The Forgotten Hero", was chosen by director Shyam Benegal because he felt that outside the state of Bengal, nobody knew who Bose really was and/or what he did for India's independence.

Citazioni:

Subhas Bose: Give me blood and I will give you freedom!

Colonna sonora:

Desh Ki Mitti

boring, embarrassing and long...

I watched this film at its world premiere at the Harvard Film Archive yesterday night (Feb 11). I went to the movie with certain amount of expectation given the subject matter and the caliber of the director. However, I was bitterly disappointed and, moreover, embarrassed by this film about Bose. Bose is a little known personality in the history of Indian independence outside of India and his contribution has been overlooked inside India for 50 years primarily due to his differences with the Gandhi-Nehru axis. As a story, Bose's biography reads like a thriller and ultimately a tragedy, and hence make a great material for a film. Shyam Benegal has been one of the leaders of alternate (non-Bollywood) cinema in India for over two decades and has made some of the best and definitive (at least in my opinion) interpretation of Indian history and effect of historical episodes on common people in cinema. His television series based on Nehru's "Discovery of India" stands out as one of the best TV series made not only in India but through the world. "Making of Mahatma", his last attempt at biographical movie about an Indian leader was a very respectable movie even if it was hampered by low budget and had some excellent acting and, importantly, more depth and a fairer balance of personality of Mahtma Gandhi than Richard Attenborough's influential film. Thus, ignoring his dismal attempts at commercial movies recently, Benegal could be interpreted as a worthy descendant of the likes of Satyajit Ray, and one could bemoan his lack of exposure in the international market. "Bose: a Forgotten Hero" was seen by many of his admirers as a comeback for this worthy director to his field of expertise. I liked the way the movie started abruptly in 1940 at the moment of Bose's resignation as the president of the INC and the script's strategy of concentrating on the events of only the last 5 years of his life. Bose's rise and fall in the hierarchy of Congress Party would itself make an full-length political movie and hence was wisely discarded by the screenwriters. The story of his dramatic escape from India, under house-arrest by the British Government & under media glare, his earnest, if misguided, attempt at forming military alliance with the Italians/Germans/Russians/Japanses forces, and finally, his failed attempt at invading India in the last days of WW2 are brought to screen in astaggering 222 minutes. The movie is structured into three sectionsdealing with one each of the three plot lines mentioned above. Thescreenplay is more or less accurate in storyline. However, it has the ultimate flaw of historical movies, which tend to treat everybody, including Bose, like caricatures. Long screenplays trying to capture the life of a person can be excused for having some of these flaws. The problem with *this* movie is that, it seems completely unedited (note some of the scenes where the camera is not even in focus). I wonder if Benegal just finished shooting and clamped together every frame he shot without even an attempt at editing. Given what I saw on screen, this movie could have been salvaged by a crisper editing to make a more fast-paced movie. As it is, the film feels more suited to be a PBS mini-series than a feature length movie. If that was the only problem with the film, I could still live with it. However, it also had the added problem of shoddy acting on part of almost every single character. Sachin Khedekar, a television actor of TV soap operas was perhaps chosen for this role because of his resemblance to S.C. Bose. He did not put much effort into understanding his character and his acting was worthy of any day-time TV soap. Some supporting acting was good but mostly seemed to be cast of filler. All the international characters seemed like non-actors picked randomly from streets who were uncomfortable being on screen or were over-compensating for lack of talent by over-acting. The romance between Bose and his Greman secretary comes out without any credibility not just because of the lack of any screen intimacy between the characters (notice how the characters rarely even touched each other, leave alone kiss on screen. As the head of the censor board of India, Benegal is well known for his puritanical/conservative views on sex) but also because of really bad acting. Even the cleverest of editing would have not been able to mask this deficiency in the movie. Lastly, I must comment on the "bollywoodization" aspect of this movie. The movie has some of the worst and most embarrassing melodrama I have seen in ages. There were SO MANY moments through the movie where the audience were bursting out with unintended giggles because of the almost campy nature of dialogs. I would be the first one to confess that Indians are a melodramatic people in general and presence of melodrama in Indian movies, even historical, is an integral part. Melodrama *does* work in Bollywood movies in enhancing the emotional impact. In this movie, however, all it does is to cheapen the storyline and, furthermore, near the end of the movie, even feels insulting when the INA soldiers are shown in such inane melodramatic state. It adds nothing to the emotional impact and takes a lot away from the tragedy being played out on screen. I think the subject deserved more respect from the actors and the director than this. This movie is hard to digest for even the Indian audience who know the history of S.C.Bose and are used to Bollywood. I wonder what message it would give to international viewers about Indian films and about Bose. To do any justice to Bose, I seriously believe, this movie should not be shown in public. I will end the review with the advice not to see this movie unless you are studying film-making, in which case, this movie is great example of how a movie should NOT be made.